February 22, 2010

Sunte hain ki

Sunte hain ki mil jaati hai har cheez dua se,
ek roz tumhein maang ke dekhenge khuda se.

jab kuchh na mila haath duaon ko uthakar,
fir haath uthane hi pade humko duaa se.

tum saamne baithe ho, to hai kaif ki baarish
woh din bhi the jab aag barasti si ghataa se

aye dil tu unhein dekh ke kuchh aise tadapna,
aa jaaye hansi unko, baithe hain khafa se.

Duniya Bhi Mili Hai Gham-e-Duniya Bhi Mila Hai
Vo Kyun Nahin Milta Jisay Maanga Tha Khuda Se

Aeene Me Vo Apni Adaa Dekh Rahe Hain
Marr Jaaye Ke Jee Jaaye Koi, Unki Bala Se

February 15, 2010

Gandhi vs Jinnah?

wrote this, sometime somewhere.

"
Gandhi & Jinnah, both were towering personalities. Both men were well read and smart enough to know, that a nation state cannot survive solely on the basis of religion, especially in today's pluralistic environment.
And somebody on this thread commented the Two nation theory was Jinnah's brainchild and he executed it. Nothing can be farther from the truth.
Those who do not read & learn from history, are bound to repeat it. The idea of a muslim nation state was that of Syed Ahmed Khan, and later Allama Iqbal (who, incidentally, penned India's national song "Saare Jahaan se achha" )
The idea was brought to fruition by scheming behind the scenes actors, who had vested interests in real estate, but needed a facade. Mr Jinnah was a very sophisticated and secular Indian, who lived most of his life in Bombay, but was convinced into the idea of Pakistan, exactly at the moment when he had a disagreement with Nehru over seat sharing in the provincial govt. under the british. Jinnah wanted a loose indian federation with equal and protected rights for all communities, including the muslims, and never a separate country.
Few pakistanis would know that the quaid recruited a Hindu poet to write Pakistan's first national anthem, thus wanting to sow the seeds of secularism in his new country. The country set out as a democratic and secular nation, but soon fell to the pressures of the zamindaars who needed the religion alibi to keep going with their feudalism.


And all this was still 70-80 YEARS ago!
Mark my words. Borders of nation states are not static. They change. The lines we've drawn on the subcontinent were not there 200 years ago. 200 years from now these won't be there. There might be a different set. Or, i pray, there may be none.


Religion:
We've all witnessed comments flying from both sides saying Hindus are that and Muslims are this.
After reading all those comments, do you not feel it is high time we just grew up.

There is nothing that we don't know. Every single person on this thread knows and believes we are humans first and hindus/muslims/christians later. If that is what it is, if that is what you know, why is it so difficult to act on this knowledge that you already have.
The venom that this Raj guy was spewing in a few posts above mine, is a result of the conditioning we give our children. We tell our children that the hindu majority schemes against the muslim minority, OR, the muslims are the in-bred lot, not nice people and what not.
You know, it is not really difficult to just stop telling your children how other religions are bad and your own is the best. Why don't we just tell them whats good about our own faith (Both the Hindu and Islamic faith, by the way, are inclusive and loving)
Let them go out and discover for themselves whats good and bad. Trust me, they'll do a better job than you can imagine, and a far better job than what we ourselves managed to do with the conditioning our parents gave us.

And the ones who are out to 'PROTECT' their faith (every religion has its bunch of nincompoops who've taken upon themselves to DEFEND their faith), please let me tell you, the day your faith starts 'needing' your protection, is the day that faith has lost its place in human consciousness. Your faith does not need you to protect it. It is far greater and taller in stature and its message to people so profound and so noble, that it has and will stand through all the tests it has to go through.

All us enlightened souls know that the whole universe and all that is contained in it, came from a single source (i'm sure you've all read 'the big bang' theory, but never thought of it in this light) then why create your own artificial differences and fight and kill over those?


Apologies for the sermonising. And about the theme of this post - india (ill)treating its minorities - and specific reference to muslims. There has to be some merit to the fact that a majority of the community's religious leaders are not doing a brilliant job. The victim paranoia, education and health of the community in general has alot to do with what is taught at the religious congregation. I mean what response would you give to the mullah, who in his friday sermon asks muslim parents to not give their children polio immunity drops because it was the hindu govt.'s 'chaal' to hurt their children. (never mind that the same medicine was being administered to all children who were brought to the healt centres, irrespective of faith)

If minorities, in general, have been ill treated and deliberately kept away from economic opportunities, what explains the the rise in fortunes of the Christian and Sikh minorities in India? In spite of the fact that both have suffered similar instances of discrimination and been at the receiving end of violence and rioting by a few fundamentalist bigots?


No nation is perfect and neither are India or Pakistan. There was and will always be crime and deviation from moral behaviour (in this case, religious discrimination). But we've to decide what is the standard deviation we want to allow in a country of one and a half billion people.

I believed the problem in India is quite the opposite. The successive governments and the system itself, is so aware of the possibility and incidence of discrimination, that to nullify the effect the past behaviour, that it has pro-actively created checks, balances, safe guards, provisions and reservations for minorities (not just religious, but also regional, ethnic, and caste based). And that, today, has become counter productive, to the extent that if any individual finds himself in the sorry state of being absent in any of the classified minorities, he is at such a disadvantage, for he will not find a reserved seat for himself in either an instititution of higher learning or for a govt employment opportunity.


The situation is such that people are fighting and rioting to have themselves classified as 'Backward Class' (it doesn't matter that they've been at the higher spectrum of the societal structure for centuries).


I think it is highly unfair to sit on a higher pedestal and judge India, and summarily declare that it systematically ill treats the minorities.

Not one country in this world is a perfect model for religious pluralism, but if you were to list out the countries who've actually done something to acknowledge and accept multiple systems of religion withing one nation state and also prevent discrimination and systematically create opportunities on the basis of merit and not an individual's subscription of a particular faith, i'd say India figures on top of that list.
"



January 9, 2009

Oilmen Strike

Oilmen strike.The insider story the government wouldn’t want you to know.

(Because the media has been gagged, and press releases issued by the employee’s unions have been snuffed out)


This is not the first time PSUs have gone on strike.And probably not the last.

Every news source on TV, newspaper and internet tells you that employees of public sector companies have gone on strike. Nobody tells you why. Every explanation stops at “strike for higher pay”.

This is what you don’t know.

1. The recommendations of the latest pay commission have not yet been implemented by the petroleum secretary. Why??

  • a. If the recommendations are implemented, the top tier employees (CMD downwards, 3-4 levels) of each of these companies will be drawing more than double the take home of the petroleum secretary, an IAS officer, and also to whom the CMDs of each of these PSUs report.
  • b. It boils down to the ego of our country’s bureaucracy who can’t really digest the fact that the competent management of these companies will be draw more salaries than themselves.
  • c. The M.J. Rao pay committee report recommendations were diluted and set for implementation, in a manner, which includes a lot of previously non – taxable components of the salary into the basic component now, which raises the tax liability of the employee and ultimately reduces his nett take home.
  • d. Usually, if the employee’s salary is increased today, effective from 1st April 2008, he would receive arrear funds (unpaid salary for some 8 months); what has happening though in the current scenario, is that since the employees’ pay will be reduced, effective from an earlier date, the employees will be required to PAY BACK their employers an arrear (in some cases amounting to Rs 1 Lakh) on account of extra salary received.
  • e. Every time employees have a grouse against the government, there is a set procedure in terms of communicating their displeasure. It mostly starts with written documents, with the names and signatures of the employee union heads going to the bureaucracy. Subsequently come small scale agitations and dharnas etc. A full scale strike is always a last resort. In the current scenario, the petroleum ministry was given an intimation, and ultimatum, way in advance of the date: 7th January 2009. The minister and the bureaucracy had ample time to respond to the pressing needs.


2. The petrol pumps across the country have gone dry due to:

  • a. The employees of ONGC and other petroleum companies going on strike.
  • b. The trucker’s strike which started 5 days prior to the PSU employees striking. And since all fuels are transported to the retail hubs via trucks, the gas stations were not receiving fresh supplies from 2nd-3rd January.
  • c. Impending 2nd phase of price reductions of motor fuels: petrol pump owners had stopped taking fresh supplies at current rates because then they would have had to suffer losses (receiving supplies at rs 45 levels and then making the sale at rs 40). This phenomenon started after the petroleum minister’s announcement last week about reducing oil prices further.


3. The people heading these agitations are not low level blue collar workers. These are technocrats in senior and middle level management of these companies. They are not your usual government babus. These are highly qualified managers and engineers running energy companies with efficiency coefficients which rival the best in the world. 

They are not doing it because they want to hold the country to ransom, but because they want what is rightfully due to them.


4. A so far unsubstantiated discussion tells us that private players in the country’s energy sector may be fuelling the unrest through the bureaucracy so that disgruntled talent from our PSUs can be weaned away to run their companies. 

- A family member of a (as yet not striking) PSU Employee

November 29, 2008

War on the Indian State : Mumbai Terrorist attacks

I will post my own comments and other reportage.

Beginning right now, i am putting up links to material that needs to be read and understood.


September 16, 2008

hit and run

BMW cars are in the news. For all the wrong reasons.

Sanjiv Nanda, accused of killing people, while at the wheel of a BMW car in 1999 was convicted recently.

And in the past one month, two more BMW cars (a 3 series and a 7 series) have been involved in hit and run cases where three lives (all of them on two wheelers) were snuffed out.

The families of the victims have all my sympathies and the erring drivers have none.

While i was at it, i couldn't rein in my brand management student mind and launched a consumer behaviour and customer profiling research on people buying BMWs.
People in the know would recall, my final year research paper also was on Car brands in India. I wrote the paper because of my interest in cars & branding. And not the other way.


Anyway, a couple of days back, a friend in my car remarked at seeing a Mercedes E280 which was in front of our car while all of us were stuck in evening rush in one of the suburbs of New Delhi, "yeh mercedes waale, bechare kitna bach bach ke chalate hain gaadi." 
I hadn't ever thought of that before but i did agree that i had never witnessed a rashly driven Mercedes. Not even the C-class or other small (in terms of physical dimensions) Mercedes cars.

That very evening we were watching gory pictures of a half smashed BMW with a gurgaon number plate, and fully smashed Bajaj Pulsar which was the ride of the unfortunate victims of the crash.

Without delving into much detail about my sources or methodology of research (because most of my comments here are coming from the gut), i'd want to think that typically a Mercedes customer is the one who has bought the car from money earned from a white business. Legitimate money. Wealth acquired by relative hard work or also passed down a generation.

The customer may also belong to a family which has been in relative comfort over the generations and the people are ones who have come to appreciate all things luxury. To appreciate craftsmanship.
This guy doesn't always think in terms of 0-100. He does however notice body roll or undulations on uneven roads. Noiselessness in the cabin rates higher on his checklist of a car purchase.

Over and above, he is buying into the three pointed star. Its his way of silently telling himself (and the world at large) that he has now what he deserved all along. And he has worked to be where he is.

While i flip through Mercedes ad campaigns over the years and across markets, by belief is strengthened further. The company also knows its customer rather well and hence the communication is also centred around the aura of the Mercedes.



However, the late entrant into the Indian premium luxury car market, the Bavarian Motor Works was already a sort of a brand for rich rebels. Even before it had a formal presence in the Indian car market, you could see second hand imports... M3s and M5s being run around on bombay roads with gay abandon. All of them self driven, by spoilt brats.

And now when it does have showrooms in Tier 1 cities, it sure is making sales at a brisk pace.
Why not? Delhi has a huge rush of nouveau riche families, who want to make more than a little noise about the wealth.

For some reason, it has to be more often than not, a Bee Emm Dabloo if not an Oddeee (Audi) to let the neighbours know.
Its even more fun, when i tell you that i have so much money that i dont give two hoots if my school going kid has some harmless (harmless for my son) fun on the beemdabloo. If something happens, we'll go and get another one.

I dont know if the company started out making engines for warplanes. Honestly i dont even care if it has a history or a legacy. But it sure goes fast. Faster than the neighbourhood Bunty's Sakoda (Škoda).

If this really is how the brand is being perceived, and if this is the profile of customers this German is after, the car will see difficult times even before it can say Achtung!

Its all good to be the ultimate driving machine, and showcase the pleasure of being involved with the car, the people at the helm will, sooner than later, have to emphasise safe driving.



This piece here is not a commentary on the quality of products offered by Mercedes or BMW. I have reserved my comments on the cars themselves. Here i have only tried to talk about the brand perception and profiled the current customer set for both brands in an Indian context.